Was the Universe Born in a Black Hole? - Horizon: What Happened Before The Big Bang? - BBC Two

About | Information | History | Online | Facts | Discovery

1. So everytime a star explodes a new universe is being born?
2. even light can't escape from black hole but the radiations are emmit by black hole.Then think which one has more speed light or gravitational waves.lhave the answer
3. then what started the first black hole....did the chicken or egg come first?
4. White hole.
5. The man who killed god! He is god lol!
6. a store??
7. WHAT IS BIG BANG??
8. I just think with all these black holes that just get bigger and bigger colliding in to each other only makes for a bigger black hole until there's only one black hole left containing everything we know, then eventually it stops spinning colliding everything inside after it's been squashed to a pin point
   
   Then exploding creating a Big Bang ?
9. We're asking the wrong question over and over, so i will explain it now, this question of what happened before the big bang is incorect. The real question should be what's happening before the big bang. You may not see it, but let me tell you why, this variation of speech is important, happened means past, like one time event, happening means something usual, happened, happens, and will happen again. For people they think universe is all there is, so before the big bang there was nothing ? Wrong, what created our universe, is happening right now, and creates other universes, and that's the direction, we should take, to understand what the big bang is, it's not an one time event. It could be a black hole, our also two other universes coliding, and creating our actual universe. In those scenarios, i am always convinced that there ain't only one universe. but many more.
10. The problem with this is that for this to happen each universe would have to get smaller and smaller each time. And the only place the matter for the universe to have would come from the star that creates a black hole. And since the continuously get smaller that would mean that it would eventually get to the size of an atom. And since the size if atoms don't shrink of expand there could be no life because the lifeforms made by each universe would be the size of atoms and would be un inteligent. And eventually it would be so small that it would consist of only one atom.
11. Seems to me the big bang created pure energy.  Where can pure energy come from?  Mass.  E=mc^2.  Whats more massive than a supermassive black hole?  Nothing.  Somehow all that mass is rapidly converted to energy.
12. This theory could be rubbish, but like biology what created the first living thing, I think if we can eventually figure out how to answer that question it may help out to refine this theory
13. this will be one of those moments where .. lets say you find out the earth is round , the sun is the middle of our system ....
    nature works the same Always , thats why it works . for humans its hard to understand a huge amount of time , or a bigger picture ...   it would be nothing but silly to know everything changes and cycles on but the universe is a mono event , came out of nothing (or god) and will end one day .
14. I don't understand how the universe can contain something that possesses characteristics of infinite but cannot be infinite itself.
15. This is probably the only conceivable theory , mainly cause we know black holes swallow up colossal amounts matter and because there is no other theory to hypothesise what caused the bb. I guess we will never know, but black holes are shrouded in mystery and like we know that physics laws didnt work in the moments after the bb , so does physics break down at the event horizon of a black hole.
16. I love reading all the simple sheep brained bible bashing comments on these videos. Why are you even here watching this if all you say is GOD MADE EVERYTHING BLAHBLAHBLAH. Open your minds for once and stop living in your imaginary friend world, Just because you can't understand it you just say 'god did it' If someone had to create the world, universe etc, who created 'god'? hrm?
17. Rubbish!!! this theory is a paradox! the problem with this theory is it may explain the creation of our universe but it doesn't explain the creation of the very first universe. 
18. Big Bang Destroyed in 9 minutes.
    Big Bang Destroyed, Correct Theory in Place-Lesson 4
19. Such a beautifully simple theory. 
20. I dont get this ... since black hole = mass and density object? It is more logical to say our universe was once a Star and then it exploded creating a black hole which is now a center of our Universe. The material of the star which exploded is now the galaxies and stars in our known Universe.  Maybe the edge of the Universe is just more space and more Universe with trillions + more of galaxies.